Story Time is fiction: a made-up story about game night. Names, people and events are invented.
Mia and I had lived together for two years. Not together together. Roommates. Separate rooms, a shared fridge shelf system she designed, and a running argument about whether the dishwasher counts as a cupboard.
We had people over on a Saturday. Nothing big, eight of us, pizza, a playlist that kept switching to someone’s gym mix. Around eleven, Jess put her phone in the middle of the coffee table and opened a drinking game. We did a few normal rounds. Somebody had to text their mom “I know what you did”. Somebody had to swap shirts with the person on their left. Fine.
Then the game switched to Hot Potato. If you’ve never played it: the phone shows a card, you pass it around while a timer ticks, and whoever is holding it when it runs out has to answer. No warning. The timer is random.
The card said: “Who here would you actually date?”
The phone went around the circle twice. People were throwing it more than passing it. I remember thinking it would land on Marco, because it always lands on Marco. It landed on me.
I had about a second and a half to come up with a joke answer. Something like “the pizza”. Something like “myself, obviously”. What came out was “Mia”.
I’d like to say the room went silent. It didn’t. It went loud. Jess actually stood up. Marco said “finally” in a way that suggested there had been a group chat about this, which, I found out later, there had been.
Mia didn’t say anything. She just looked at me with this face I’d never seen on her, sort of surprised and sort of like she was doing math.
I tried to blame the timer. I said it was random, it was a reflex, I was just saying the first name I saw. Everyone agreed that was a very convincing explanation and nobody believed it, including me.
The game moved on. Someone got a dare to speak in an accent for three rounds. I didn’t hear any of it.
After everyone left, I was doing the dishes, mostly so I’d have something to do with my hands. Mia came into the kitchen, leaned on the counter and said, “So. The timer.”
I said, “The timer.”
She said, “I would’ve said you too, by the way. If it landed on me.”
Then she put a plate in the dishwasher, which she knows I hate, and went to bed.
We talked properly the next morning. Over coffee, both a little embarrassed, both very aware that we still had eleven months left on the lease no matter how this went. We agreed to try. Carefully. One dinner first, like normal people who don’t already share a bathroom.
That was eight months ago. We moved into her room, turned mine into an office, and the dishwasher argument is still going.
Jess takes full credit. I keep telling her it was the timer.
The game in this story
Not Another Drinking Game is a pass-the-phone party game for 2 to 12 players: dares, votes, confessions and mini games. Any drink counts as a sip, and nobody has to drink to play. Free on Android.
More stories: Story Time.

