Story Time is fiction: a made-up story about game night. Names, people and events are invented.
Marco was the friend with the good watch. The weekend in Barcelona. The new jacket every time you saw him. He was the one who’d say “I got this” when the bill came and actually mean it.
So when a Most Likely To card came up at my birthday, “Most likely to secretly be broke”, everybody pointed at him as a joke. That was the whole point of the joke. It was the least likely answer, which made it funny.
Eight fingers on Marco. He had to drink. He did, and he laughed, and then he kind of stopped laughing in the middle of it.
Nobody noticed except me, because I was sitting next to him. He put the glass down and stared at the card for a second too long.
The game kept going. Two more rounds. Then Marco said, quietly, not really to anyone: “It’s not that funny, actually.”
Somebody said “what?” and he said it again, louder. And then, because I think he’d been holding it for a long time and the card just knocked it loose, he told us. Thirty-eight thousand on credit cards. Four cards. Minimum payments on all of them, and the minimums kept going up. The watch was on one. Barcelona was on two.
Here’s what I didn’t expect: nobody made it weird. Our friend Ivana, who works in accounting and is usually the least emotional person in any room, just grabbed a napkin and a pen from the kitchen and said, “Okay. Interest rates. Go.”
So that’s what we did on my birthday. Eight people around a coffee table, a drinking game paused on the screen, building a debt payoff plan on a napkin. Highest interest card first. Ivana did the math. Someone found an app for tracking it. Someone else said they’d been in the same spot two years ago, which none of us knew either.
Marco cried a little. Not dramatically. Just the tired kind.
It’s been a year. He’s paid off two of the cards. He sold the watch, which he says he doesn’t miss, and which I don’t believe. We switched our group dinners to someone’s apartment instead of restaurants, and nobody’s complained once.
The napkin is on his fridge. It’s got a pizza stain on it and Ivana’s handwriting, and every time a card hits zero, he crosses it out and sends a photo to the group chat.
I think about that card sometimes. It was supposed to be a joke. It was a joke. It just happened to be the joke that let him say the true thing.
The game in this story
Not Another Drinking Game is a pass-the-phone party game for 2 to 12 players: dares, votes, confessions and mini games. Any drink counts as a sip, and nobody has to drink to play. Free on Android.
More stories: Story Time.

