My Best Friend’s Husband Drank on the Wrong Card

Fiction. Never Have I Ever, one question too far, and the hardest conversation of a long friendship.

Story Time is fiction: a made-up story about game night. Names, people and events are invented.

Nora and I have been best friends since we were nineteen. I was a bridesmaid at her wedding. I helped her pick the paint for the nursery that turned into a home office when they decided kids could wait. Her husband, Tom, I’d known for eight years. He was fine. Nice. The kind of guy who fixes your sink without being asked.

We were at their place for a game night, six of us. Never Have I Ever came up and it was the usual stuff for a while. Never have I ever lied on a CV. Never have I ever eaten something off the floor at a restaurant. Laughing, drinking, nothing serious.

Then the card: “Never have I ever been in love with someone in this room.”

Nora drank, because she’s married to Tom, and she made a big show of it. Our friends Ben and Liv drank, same reason. That’s four.

Tom drank too. Which, fine, he’s married to Nora, that makes sense.

Except he wasn’t looking at Nora when he did it. He was looking at me.

It was maybe one second. Maybe less. I don’t think anyone else saw it. I told myself I’d imagined it. I spent the rest of the night not looking at him, and I left early, saying I had a headache.

He texted me two days later. A long text. It said a lot of things, but the main one was that he’d felt this way for a while, that he’d never act on it, that he was sorry for the card, and that he “just needed me to know”. I read it in a car park and felt sick.

I didn’t reply. I called Nora instead.

That was the hardest phone call of my life. I kept trying to find a way to say it that wouldn’t hurt her, and there wasn’t one. So I just read her the text.

She was quiet for a long time. Then she said, “I think I knew something was off. I didn’t know it was this.”

I was sure I’d lose her. Not because I’d done anything, but because sometimes that’s how it goes. The messenger gets blamed. I’d have understood.

She showed up at my apartment the next night with a bottle of wine and her laptop and said, “I’m not leaving him tonight. But I’m not losing you either. Help me figure out what to say.”

They did a year of couples counseling. I don’t know all of it and I don’t ask. Tom and I are polite now, at a distance. Nora and I are closer than we’ve ever been, which I didn’t think was possible.

We still play games when it’s just us. We skip that card.

The game in this story

Not Another Drinking Game is a pass-the-phone party game for 2 to 12 players: dares, votes, confessions and mini games. Any drink counts as a sip, and nobody has to drink to play. Free on Android.

More stories: Story Time.