Story Time is fiction: a made-up story about game night. Names, people and events are invented.
My cousin Ela’s bachelorette was in a rented house by the lake. Twelve of us, matching pajamas she pretended to hate, a cake shaped like something I won’t describe here. We’d planned games all night, including a bachelorette pack on someone’s phone where the bride gets picked at the start and half the cards are about her.
It was going great. Ela had to do her best impression of her fiancé. Ela had to rate every guest’s dating history out of ten. Ela had to call him and say she’d adopted a goat. He laughed. We all laughed.
Then: “Bride, tell everyone the exact moment you knew he was the one.”
It’s the easiest card in the pack. It’s practically a gift. You say the cute story, everyone goes “aww”, you drink, done.
Ela opened her mouth and nothing came out. She laughed, said “oh, there are so many”, and then didn’t name one. She tried again. “When we… no, okay, when he…” She stopped. The room got very quiet in that way where everyone suddenly finds their drink interesting.
Her maid of honor jumped in and made a joke and moved the game along. Ela laughed with everyone. But later I found her on the dock, alone, with her pajama hood up.
She said, “I can’t think of one. Isn’t that weird? I should be able to think of one.”
I didn’t tell her what to do. It wasn’t my place. I just said that it was okay to not know, and that a card in a party game wasn’t a verdict. She said, “No. But it’s a pretty good question.”
Three weeks later, she postponed the wedding. Not cancelled. Postponed. She said they needed time to figure out whether they were getting married because they wanted to or because they’d already booked the venue. They’re still figuring it out. They’re still together, for now, and talking more honestly than they had in years.
She told me once that she’s weirdly grateful for that card. Not because it ruined anything. Because it asked the question she’d been avoiding, at a party, surrounded by people who loved her, instead of at the altar.
The game in this story
Not Another Drinking Game is a pass-the-phone party game for 2 to 12 players: dares, votes, confessions and mini games. Any drink counts as a sip, and nobody has to drink to play. Free on Android.
More stories: Story Time.

